Julie Mills is heartbroken when her rock star wannabe boyfriend Ronny dumps her. With encouragement from her best friend Eve, Julie decides to post an online ad to attract a date. After a few too many sips of wine, Julie posts an ad entitled: "Easy Lady Requests Guy with Two Socks".
Easy Lady meets Dan the Man at an Italian restaurant. It is far from the night Julie expects, and not just because it involves an eye patch and an argyle sock. When Ronny comes back from the road a 'changed man', Julie must decide if she wants the man she says she loves, or the man she just might.